Federal judge rejects domestic violence defense in Brazilian grandparents’ kidnapping case

CARI – Child Abduction Recovery International

A federal judge in Houston has affirmed a jury’s guilty verdict last month for a Brazilian couple tried on allegations they helped their daughter in the international kidnapping of their 8-year-old grandson, in a case that garnered widespread attention from top officials in two countries.

920x920.jpg

Following the guilty verdict, defense lawyers asked the judge to reconsider the verdict.

U.S. District Judge Alfred H. Bennett ruled Monday that a reasonable juror could have concluded beyond a reasonable doubt the husband and wife helped kidnap their grandson Nico.

A reasonable juror, he said, could also have concluded based on the majority of the evidence that their daughter, codefendant Marcelle Guimaraes, was not fleeing a pattern or incident of domestic violence when she left Houston with the boy in 2013 and settled in Brazil. This so-called “affirmative defense” — that they had reason to believe she was in danger — could have effectively canceled out the kidnapping charges against them, which is what defense lawyers had asked the judge to do.

Defense attorney Rusty Hardin, who represents the boy’s grandfather, declined to comment on the ruling.

On May 25, the jury found Carlos, 67, and his wife Jemima Guimaraes, 66, guilty of helping in an international parental kidnapping. The jury acquitted them both of conspiracy to kidnap the child.

The jury verdict followed a three-week trial in which the boy’s father, a physician at Baylor College of Medicine, testified at length about his turbulent relationship with the child’s mother, who worked at an investment firm. In 2013, she violated their joint custody agreement in Harris County when she took their son to a family wedding in Brazil and never returned.

JURY VERDICT: Split verdict in grandparents’ international kidnapping case 

The couple’s daughter was also indicted and is considered a fugitive in the case. She remains in Brazil.

In the years she has been gone, state and federal courts in both countries have taken up the question of where the boy, Nico Brann, should live.

The judge had indicated following the verdict that he had questions about it he was willing to consider. Upon receiving the verdict slip from the jury foreman, Bennett sat looking at the paper for several minutes before reading it aloud. He did not formally accept the jury’s decision. Instead, he explained, once the jury had left the room that he needed time to consider defense attorneys’ request that the grandparents should be cleared based on their argument that their daughter was fleeing domestic violence.

“As the judge of this court, I have to make a determination if judgment notwithstanding the verdict is appropriate,” Bennett told the lawyers. “I want to think on it.”

The child’s father, Dr. Christopher Brann, sought intervention from judges, diplomats and politicians in a five-year campaign to bring his son Nico back to the U.S., resulting in a letter from the bipartisan Senate Judiciary Committee, including U.S. Senators Ted Cruz and John Cornyn of Texas, urging the Trump administration to “use every possible tool” to bring the child back.

CALL FOR INTERVENTION: Senators call for return of Houston boy, allegedly kidnapped by mother

The federal court in Brazil determined the child should remain there with his mother. That ruling is on appeal.

In the meantime, Brann reported what the executive branches of the U.S. and Brazil both consider a parental abduction to the FBI in 2015, which led to a criminal indictment.

Source

If you have any questions or concerns regarding International Parental Child Abduction feel free to contact CARI Child Abduction Recovery International 24/7. We are always available at info@childabductionrecovery.com or by calling our CEO Adam Whittington directly +46 707385598

http://www.childabductionrecovery.com

http://www.childrecoveryaustralia.com.au

cropped-ce48e115-92e3-4f32-aae7-f85d7de6fada-15431-000003fd2b8405e3

child recovery services

whittington cari

child recovery

Advertisements